Bridging the Way BayState Business Brokers blog

Should You Buy an Existing Franchise or Open a New One?

by | Mar 19, 2014

If you are thinking of buying a business, franchises have a lot of appeal.  They have a track record.  Many are household names.  Most have an operating manual that gives you the information on how to operate the business.  If you need assistance, they have people available to help you.  But, should you buy an existing franchise for sale or open a new franchise location?

The first thing you should recognize is that buying a franchise, no matter how many there are or how well known they are, is not a guarantee that you will be successful.  Just like a non-franchise business, there are successful franchises and unsuccessful franchises.  The same is true of individual locations.

As part of the process of buying a franchise, you will receive a Franchise Disclosure Document.  Franchises are required by law to give you a copy before you buy a franchise.
This document has important information!  Read it.  It will give you information about conflicts between the franchisor and the franchisees.  It will tell you how many new franchises were sold and how many closed.  It may give you information on how much an average franchisee does in sales or earnings.  It will give you a list of the franchisees.  Contact several and ask them questions about the franchise.  Do your due diligence.

The primary reasons to buy an existing franchise are the same reasons you buy an existing business – to reduce the risk of going into business and to start out with employees, customers, and an immediate cashBuy existing franchise or start new one flow.  As I pointed out, buying a known franchise is no guarantee of success.  Buying one that is up and running reduces this risk since you can see how the business has been doing.  There is no waiting to ramp up and start making money.  Both of these benefits are worth something.  In many instances, you can buy an existing franchise at little more than the cost of opening a franchise.

If the franchise is doing well, it is likely that existing franchisees have bought up many of the best territories.  In the case of some franchises, when a good franchisee wants to sell, they steer the sale to a good current franchisee so they have a good operator running the business.  In this case, their interests are not to get the best deal for the franchisee.  Many franchisees recognize this and sell their business through a business broker.  Exposing it to the market will usually result in more buyer interest and a higher selling price.

I have to give you a warning.  When you talk to the franchisor, they are likely to try to convince you to open a new franchise rather than buy an existing one.  We have had this happen to buyers, who were buying an existing franchise, several times.  This is self-serving to the franchisor.  If you buy an existing franchisee, they don’t gain anything.  But, if you open a new franchise, you may be successful and increase the overall revenues of the franchisor.  If you are dealing with a local franchise representative, it is likely that they will get a commission on your purchase of a new franchise – but not on a sale of an existing franchise.

There are many good franchises.  But, like any business that is started, there is no guarantee of success and how well a new location will do can vary significantly.  Give consideration to buying an existing franchise to reduce your risk and start out with employees, customers, and a cash flow.

Latest Posts

Preparing to sell your business: Start with preparing emotionally

If you are thinking about or planning to sell your business, give yourself some time to get prepared, including emotionally. Six Steps to Start Preparing Give yourself the necessary time to prepare.You should allow 2-5 years to plan your exit. The unfortunate reality...

Market Insight by Analyzing Pursuits

I am constantly asked, how is the market? With rising consumer costs and the war with Iran, there are many macro factors that affect buyer and seller sentiment. Axial recently released an interesting report reflecting pursuit activity through the first half of 2026....

Three Considerations when Choosing a Business Broker

Deciding to sell your business is a big decision. So is deciding to buy one. Whether you are looking to sell your business or looking to buy a business, evaluating and choosing the right business broker may directly affect the outcome. Watch this video to learn more...

Five Takeaways from Axial’s 2026 Buyer Landscape Report

BayState Business Brokers is a proud member of Axial’s deal platform for the lower and middle market. Their recent report provided an update on buyer trends and the buyer landscape for the lower middle market (under $10.0+ million in EBITDA). Five Key Takeaways: The...

Top of the Funnel Q4 2025 Market Activity Released by Axial

Axial has released its analysis of top of the funnel activity on its deal platform for the lower-middle-market for Q4 2025.* Total deals for Q4 2025 on the Axial platform were up 11.7% over Q4 2024, indicating a highly active lower-middle market with 2,854 deals...

Benefits of a Town Hall Meeting for the Seller and Prospective Buyers

Protecting a seller’s time during the sale of their business is one of many priorities that our business brokers have when quarterbacking the process from listing a business through a successful close. At BayState Business Brokers, we put our experience, knowledge and...

Leading with Passion: Sarah Grossman’s Journey

Sarah Grossman, principal and owner of BayState Business Brokers has an entrepreneurial spirit and is passionate about her team, her clients and her family. Starting at a young age, she understood the importance of how small businesses fueled the economy. Her father...

Meet Business Broker Phil Masotta

Phil Masotta, Business Broker, is a trusted advisor to business owners going through one of the most impactful life choices they’ll experience. With a 25-year track record in mergers and acquisitions, Phil focuses on selling business-to-business services companies,...

Meet Business Broker Ed Burkhart

Ed Burkhart, Business Broker at BayState Business Brokers, with a background in owning and selling automotive and construction companies, has a unique understanding of what it takes to grow, manage and then sell businesses, offering tremendous insight to his clients....

Due Diligence: The Foundation of a Successful Sale

Sarah Grossman, Principal of BayState Business Brokers, has over a decade of experience facilitating the sale of clients’ businesses, and she knows the real work begins after the offer is signed. That real work is due diligence: the period of time when the buyer is...

Axial Recognizes Top 25 Business Brokers for Lower Middle Market

Sarah Grossman, Principal of BayState Business Brokers, is pleased to be recognized by Axial as one of the top 25 brokerages serving the lower middle market. Their semi-annual Business Brokers League Table for firms with revenue $10 million or below was recently...

Thinking of selling your business? Ignore the noise.

Attention business owners who are you thinking of selling: ignore the economic noise and the stock market fluctuations. Really. It’s a Seller’s Market If you are closely monitoring economic indicators and the stock market indices to help you decide if it is time to...

Negotiating a Deal: The Benefits of Using a Business Broker

In a recent article from Sell Your Way, Sarah Grossman, Principal and Owner of BayState Business Brokers, shares her expertise on the important role of a business broker including negotiating the deal. Sarah, a Certified Business Intermediary, emphasizes the value a...

Steps

Thinking of selling your business?

Let’s meet to discuss your business and goals whether you are READY to sell now, THINKING of selling or PLANNING ahead to sell in the coming years. We’re here to maximize your ROI.

Call us at 617-562-5700 or Contact

Hands

Looking to buy a business?

Let’s meet to discuss your goals to connect you with one of our experienced business brokers who offer extensive local market knowledge and industry knowledge.

Call us at 617-562-5700 or Contact